The Public Good and the Lottery

Lottery is a form of gambling in which people purchase tickets for a chance to win a prize, usually cash. State governments at all levels have used lotteries to raise money for a variety of purposes, from public works projects and education to state employees’ salaries and even to pay off debts. Lotteries are a key part of the state budget in most states, and there is always pressure to increase lottery revenues.

While the precise rules vary, state lotteries follow remarkably similar patterns: the state creates a monopoly for itself; establishes a state agency or public corporation to run the lottery; begins operations with a modest number of relatively simple games; and, because it is constantly seeking additional revenue, progressively expands the lottery in terms of both the number and the complexity of available games. In the process, the government promotes an activity that has many negative consequences for poor people and problem gamblers.

Historically, the main argument in favor of a state lottery has been that it is an effective way to raise painless revenue without burdening the general population with direct taxes. The idea is that the public will voluntarily spend a trifling sum for the chance of substantial gain, and this is a much more appealing argument in an anti-tax era than the prospect of paying a higher tax rate to fund a particular public project.

But studies have shown that the underlying dynamic is somewhat different. Lotteries are very popular in times of financial stress because they provide a tempting alternative to higher taxes or cuts in spending on public programs. However, the popularity of a lottery does not appear to be tied to a state’s actual fiscal condition; states with healthy state budgets also enjoy wide public support for lotteries.

To attract players, a lottery must send two distinct messages. The first is the idea that the experience of scratching a ticket is a fun, novel, and exciting one. This is coded to appeal to a wide variety of psychological and behavioral factors, including an irrational attachment to the idea that numbers on a ticket are “lucky” or “unlucky.”

The second message is the more important one. The goal is to convince the public that lotteries are a good thing because they benefit a state’s public good. This is a very difficult sell. The evidence is clear that the money raised by a lottery is a small fraction of total state revenue. Lottery commissions have responded by focusing on specific uses of the proceeds and promoting the notion that lottery funds are well spent.

Many, but not all, state lotteries provide statistical information after the draw. For example, you can learn how often a specific number has been drawn, which numbers are most frequently drawn and how much the prize amounts have varied over time. You can also compare the odds of winning various prizes to determine which ones are most attractive. But this kind of information can be misleading if the public is not aware that the odds of winning are largely determined by the size and composition of the player pool.